What the Fox

What the Fox

Edan Alexander Is Free. But Now He’s a Pawn in a Qatari PR Stunt.

Why one hostage’s freedom is being used to launder terror, score political points, and sell the world a story that just isn’t true.

Peter Fox's avatar
Peter Fox
May 12, 2025
∙ Paid
4
4
Share

Edan Alexander is free!

The last living American hostage held by Hamas has finally been released from captivity after surviving 584 days underground in unthinkable conditions.

That’s a miracle. And also… if Qatar can get one hostage out, they can get the rest of the 58 out too.

It’s the kind of fuckery that compounds the sadness of the whole situation.

This isn’t a ceasefire breakthrough.
This isn’t even really diplomacy.

It’s theater.

It was essentially a trade. A PR stunt for Trump and Qatar.

Any life saved is worth celebrating. But behind the scenes? Shit is wacky.

Let’s keep score:

  • Trump negotiated directly with Hamas.
    Not with Israel.

  • Edan’s release came hours before Trump’s big Middle East trip.
    Timing? Not coincidental.
    The PR machine is PR-ing.

  • Hamas gave up nothing else.
    No prisoner swap. No ceasefire.

    Enter Qatar

    Qatar is out here playing all sides like it’s poker night and they’re the dealer and the house.

    • They just gifted Trump a $400M jet.
      Which, hi, might violate the Emoluments Clause a.k.a. “you can’t take foreign sugar daddy gifts if you’re president unless Congress says ‘yes,’” and they didn’t say yes.

    • In exchange, Qatar got a seat in Trump’s inner circle. They get to rebrand themselves as peace mediators while continuing to fund Hamas behind the scenes.

This isn’t generosity. It’s pay-to-play.

Somehow, Donald Trump ends up looking like the hero of the hostage crisis while Israel stands there like the last kid picked on the playground.

Trump made this deal behind Israel’s back, while Qatar played matchmaker and the rest of us played “guess who’s being manipulated again!”

Edan Alexander should be in Israel on his own terms. Instead, he’s rumored to be flying to Qatar in the coming days for a photo op with Trump.

Yes. QATAR.
The same country that funded, sheltered, cheered, and negotiated the exact terms of his suffering. It’s like going from one kind of hostage situation to another.

Keep reading with a 7-day free trial

Subscribe to What the Fox to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2025 Peter Fox
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start writingGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture